View Profile Catalystl

All 5 Audio Reviews

1 w/ Response

I don't remember how, but a while ago I found your Pulse Palpitation bandcamp and I really liked your Creepy Miku EP you put up there. I was surprised to see it here and I kind of hate the name but I still think this is a good opening track, I wish you made more stuff like this.

As for my actual review, I think the song's repetetiveness and high pitch can get a little irratating, and my favorite part is from 0:34 to 1:00, it gives off a unique vibe.

This is funny and would go well with some shitpost games, but it's hard to sense a pattern in it. Also it would be better if there were sections with different instruments throughout the song.

It sounds fine to listen to, but it feels like there's no structure, since most sections don't repeat much, and they all sound really similar. I think the best part is from 00:25 to 00:30.

Also the instrument sounds from Online Sequencer are just bank 0 midi patches. That's not a critique of the song, just fyi.

It's good, but kind of rough around the edges.

The 4 main notes that play at 00:10 sound out of tune, and the drums at 00:36 sound bland since they repeat so fast. I also think the part of the song starting at 00:36 goes on for too long without much variation.

Lastly, I think the instruments were good, and maybe it would sound better with more.

I can't hear the instruments at the beginning well and the percussion is bland.

Around 00:40, the note that plays longer than the other ones sounds very out of place and ruins the flow.

Other than that, I think the song is okay and sounds good at 01:36.

Dankdadd responds:

You can't hear it well at the beginning because I tried to make it fade in by gradually increasing the volume, and yeah I've been working on percussion for a while, can't seem to get it right.

I think what you're talking about around 40 seconds is that I looped the chorus, and since the chorus ends with the same note it starts with, it might be a little awkward.

And lol, I thought 1:36 was the weakest part of the song I made, but I'm glad you enjoyed it.

Thanks for the review.

I make dumb games when I get bored

15, Male




Joined on 2/26/20

Exp Points:
3,363 / 3,600
Exp Rank:
Vote Power:
5.98 votes
Safety Patrol
Global Rank:
B/P Bonus:
3m 10d